What's working this week is Audiencers' weekly round-up of the numbers, tests and benchmarks that show what's working in digital reader revenue right now. It's a curated selection, not a news digest: we only keep insights on the topics we cover, engagement, conversion and retention, and the models behind them, from subscriptions and memberships to registration, newsletters and apps. Each insight comes with a "What this means for you" takeaway written by the Audiencers team. This edition draws on data collected up to 13 November 2026. Some figures come from earlier reports in our archive, and each one shows the period it covers.
The number of the week: 134%
At the Financial Times, readers on a trial who sign up to a newsletter are 134% more likely to be retained than those who don’t. The figure comes from FT Strategies’ report on its 2025 EMEA Subscriptions Academy.
Acquire and register
- Only 4% of unique visitors are regular readers
In a Lenfest Institute study of US local publishers, regular readers (more than five articles a month) made up just 4% of unique visitors at the typical publisher. Readers viewing eight or more articles a month were much more likely to subscribe (period not stated). Source: Elements of Audience Engagement
What this means for you: Whilst metered models work well for converting your most engaged audiences, a dynamic paywall is really the most effective for adapting the journey to a reader’s propensity to subscribe. Poool for instance divides audiences into 4 engagement groups, allowing publishers to build engagement and conversion journeys for each segment, with adapted conversion steps, design and messaging.
- Logged-in users convert at 10x the rate of anonymous ones
Piano’s client data shows known (logged-in) users subscribe at ten times the rate of anonymous visitors, one of the main arguments for registration walls such as the Guardian’s in 2023. Global; period not stated. Source: Elements of Audience Engagement
Poool found similar findings. At Broadsheet, for instance, the cohort of registered, newsletter-engaged users, which accounts for a tiny 0.7% fraction of the total audience, drives a disproportionate 43% of all digital subscription conversions. This equates to an extraordinary over-indexing factor of 61x. Registration hooks the high-intent reader, and the newsletter sequentially delivers the repeat paywall exposure required to close the sale.
- Five unlocked archive investigations reached 500,000+ users
South Africa’s News24 made five archive investigations free for 24 hours each over one week, then put them back behind the paywall with subscribe and register prompts. It reached more than 500,000 users and built a pool of 23,000 engaged readers to retarget with offers (Subscriptions Academy EMEA 2025). Source: FT Strategies / Google News Initiative
What this means for you: this emphasises the importance of your content access model, adapted to the content type and potentially the time since publication too. We’re seeing increasingly more publishers test a hard paywall on their archived content, Forum Communications for instance, opening a fairly successful acquisition channel.
Convert
- A paywalled hockey livestream converted at 5%, 3x earlier streams
The Minnesota Star Tribune (US) put a high school hockey livestream behind its paywall and saw a 5% conversion rate, three times that of previous livestreams. This led it to build Strib Varsity, with team and athlete pages (2024-2026). Source: American Press Institute (via Better News)
What this means for you: It’s always worth experimenting with what’s behind the paywall, sometimes with dedicated offers to convert those Audiences. DC Thomson launched a sports subscription offer for their sports fans who weren’t interested in other content.
- A clearer paywall design brought 60% more conversions
In an A/B test, Courrier International (France) redesigned its paywall with a clear €3.99 a month entry price, a bigger Subscribe button and Google Pay. The new version brought 60% more conversions than the old one (Subscriptions Academy EMEA 2025). Source: FT Strategies / Google News Initiative
What this means for you: Small tweaks can make a big difference when it comes to converting, but also don’t underestimate the power of regularly changing paywall design to avoid blindness to your offers.
Onboard and engage
Puzzle players read 51% more articles
At UK publisher Stylist, people who play its puzzles read 51% more articles, and it has moved 90% of its once-free puzzles behind the paywall (2026). Source: MediaVoices
What this means for you: The New Yorker tested this last year, as they’d found puzzle players to be some of the most engaged, and coming to the site directly. Even getting 1% of the free puzzle-playing audience to convert to a subscriber had great revenue potential. The key however was a games-specific paywall that balanced engagement and conversion.
Retain
- Newsletter sign-ups make triallists 134% more likely to stay
Financial Times (UK) trial readers who subscribe to a newsletter are 134% more likely to be retained (report on Subscriptions Academy EMEA 2025). Source: FT Strategies / Google News Initiative
What this means for you: Forming habits to increase frequency of visits is one of the smartest ways to increase retention.
- A longer grace period cut failed-payment stops by 21%
The Seattle Times (US) extended its grace period to 27 days, added card retries and updater runs, and messaged logged-in readers with expiring cards. Stops for non-payment fell 21% (2019-2021, reported June 2021). Source: Better News
What this means for you: Failed payments are one of the biggest sources of churn. Finding a technology or solution to this issue can pay very well.
- 42% of paying subscribers didn’t visit in a month
The Arizona Republic (US) found 42% of its paying digital subscribers didn’t visit monthly. Stories built for these ‘zombie’ subscribers got about a 20% click rate among them, against 2% for an average story (2019-2020, Table Stakes). Source: Better News
Product and apps
- Audio lifts top apps’ median monthly usage from 200 to 1,000 minutes
Pugpig’s benchmark of about 440 publisher apps shows that adding audio raises median monthly usage among top performers from 200 to 1,000 minutes; top apps average 40 sessions a month and more than 20 minutes per session (2026). Source: MediaVoices
- App users who listen to audio are 9x more likely to return
Stylist (UK) says app users who listen to any audio are nine times more likely to come back, and subscriber conversion is stronger in its app than on the web (2026; no app-versus-web figure given).
Source: MediaVoices
